02/10/03 Regular - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

Session 1868 February 10, 2003 Tobias Gibson, 1058 Reisler Avenue, responded to statements made by previous speakers by stating that U.S. involvement in previous wars were by an act of Congress or were an action by the United Nations. He believed that the war on terrorism did not fit those standards. He asked Council to approve the resolution. Mayor Adams responded to statements about the propriety of a local government entity formulating a resolution about federal legislation. He said that federal legislation could not preclude comments and responses from Council. He noted that government has "put the Constitution in the closet" in the past; vigilance and response by local government was a critical force for accountability. Mr. Munkel thanked the citizens for their comments. He said that were some good provisions in the Patriot Act therefore he could not support total repeal. After asking how many of those present had actually read the act, he addressed statements that 9/11 occurred due to a failure of intelligence; he observed that the Patriot Act was a remedy for the failure of intelligence agencies to share information. Mr. Munkel also advised citizens on the importance of directing their comments and concerns about expansion of the Act to their Congressmen. Mr. Lieberman said that the resolution, as now prepared, was not anti-Patriot Act; it did not call for repeal. He maintained that some stands taken by the federal government on certain provisions of the act could lead to infringement upon civil liberties; the intent of the resolution was to protect residents against such actions. The resolution directed the City Manager to mandate that City employees must guarantee fundamental constitutional rights when asked to assist investigations. Ms. Welsch said that she believes this is a dangerous time for our country and she considered the Patriot Act a symbol of that dangerous time. She stated that it is easy to ignore what is happening if it is not happening to you, personally. There is no way to know whether the Patriot Act has affected the lives of people in University City, because under the provisions of the Patriot Act, we don't have to be told. Ms. Welsch said she would be proud if the City Council passed this resolution. Mr. Sharpe spoke in support of Mr. Munkel's suggestion that citizens contact federal elected officials about their concerns about the Act. Ms. Colquitt also advised those present to communicate with federal elected officials. She also stated that the main function of local government entity was to protect its citizens. Mayor Adams thanked those present for their input and comments. He also stated that there had been several modifications to the Resolution.